Examining Short Prints

Deciding which cards are short prints along with the order of difficulty of those short prints is a favorite subject of Post cereal football collectors. It is a subjective topic because each collector's experience gathering cards is different.

The ranking process shown below was done by combining rankings for two lists: 1) product scarcity and 2) sales prices.

For the product (cereal brand and size) scarcity list, a percentage for each card was calculated based on a ranking of the scarcity of the panel(s) on which the card appeared. First, the total number of cards for each player on each product panel on which they appeared is compiled. Second, all counts from the same products are totaled. This number is divided by the total of all cards to get a percentage of cards from each product.

Now it gets a little complicated. Some Post cereal football panels were double printed within the product, explaining why some short prints are rarer than others. For instance, it is known that Sugar Coated Corn Flakes 10 oz. boxes were printed six at a time with every revolution of the rotogravure cylinder, even though there are only four different back panel configurations. This means that there were two panels printed one time and two panels printed two times as the cylinders with the six panels rolled ink onto paper with each revolution. It is unknown what the actual order was for the printing of SCCF10 boxes, but for illustrative purposes, let's use the following configuration. In a print setup of three boxes horizontally across the paper roll and two rows vertically the layout could have been one box of panel 145 and two boxes of panel 15 in the first row followed by one box of panel 153 and two boxes of panel 54 in the second row. Thus, six boxes were printed at a time.

This means that there were twice as many cards from boxes with panels 15 and 54 as there were boxes with panels 145 and 153. In order to account for double printing, still using SCCF10 panels as our example, the number calculated above for percentage of cards from each product would be divided by 42 for cards from panels 145 and 153, as there is a 1/42 chance of getting a particular card from one of the six seven-card SCCF10 panels. Cards from panels 15 and 54 would be divided by 21 as there is a 2/42 (1/21) chance of getting one of those double printed cards. This process was repeated for each of the double printed products. Then, percentages were calculated for each of the 528 cards that fill up all of the 99 panels printed for the Post cereal football promotion. The percentage of cards from more than one product was aggregated for all 200 cards. For example #145 Jerry Tubbs' percentage of SCCF10 and OF10 cards was added together to get a total panel percentage for that card. The list of 200 was then sorted from low to high total percentage and assigned a rank.

The product scarcity ranking by itself, in theory at least, should be the most objective scarcity ranking method since it is based on numbers of cards on panels produced. For example, Jess Richardson (41) and Jim Gibbons (48) were both on Post Tens and Post Toasties 8 oz. panels. These products were printed so that each of the three Post Toasties 8 oz. panels were printed in the exact same quantity. The same is true for Post Tens panels. Thus, Gibbons' and Richardson's total production numbers are exactly the same and the product scarcity table on the left side reflects that.

Price ranking was done by sorting average sales price for all 200 cards. The highest average priced card (#93 Dave Baker) was at the top of the list and received a rank of 1. In descending price order, the rest of the cards follow.

To get a final ranking, the ranking of product scarcity was added to the ranking of average price per card. The combined scores were sorted and the lowest scores are being used to present a list of overall scarcity.

Following is a chart of the product, price and combined scarcity rankings. The lists are presented here with the products on which the cards appeared shown at right.

Scarcity Ranks
		Product Ranks				Price		Combined Scarcity Ranks
Rank	Card	Player	Product %	Rank	Card	Player	Price	Rank	Card	Player	Total Rank
1	93	Dave Baker	0.161%	1	93	Dave Baker	491.28	1	93	Dave Baker	2
2	117	Larry Morris	0.209%	2	74	Sam Baker	226.60	2	74	Sam Baker	10
3	28	Del Shofner	0.216%	3	61	Jim Brown	112.99	3	117	Larry Morris	11
4	153	Bill Koman	0.221%	4	193	Joe Krakoski	107.42	4	110	Angelo Coia	13
5	110	Angelo Coia	0.248%	5	10	Tom Moore	106.65	5	10	Tom Moore	14
6	29	Y. A. Tittle	0.252%	6	111	Mike Ditka	86.67	6	28	Del Shofner	14
7	164	Art Hunter	0.253%	7	139	Allen Green	82.28	7	29	Y. A. Tittle	16
8	74	Sam Baker	0.258%	8	110	Angelo Coia	73.15	8	193	Joe Krakoski	23
9	10	Tom Moore	0.258%	9	117	Larry Morris	55.73	9	145	Jerry Tubbs	28
10	47	Gail Cogdill	0.260%	10	29	Y. A. Tittle	54.07	10	153	Bill Koman	29
11	163	Carroll Dale	0.265%	11	28	Del Shofner	48.78	11	136	Mike Connelly	31
12	54	Darris McCord	0.276%	12	103	Bob St. Clair	46.42	12	111	Mike Ditka	32
13	9	Max McGee	0.277%	13	136	Mike Connelly	46.26	13	163	Carroll Dale	34
14	145	Jerry Tubbs	0.282%	14	145	Jerry Tubbs	46.06	14	9	Max McGee	35
15	55	Jim Martin	0.282%	15	141	Bob Lilly	45.83	15	54	Darris McCord	39
16	68	John Morrow	0.291%	16	176	Don Joyce	45.75	16	169	Jack Pardee	39
17	43	Bobby Walston	0.292%	17	181	Dick Pesonen	43.14	17	176	Don Joyce	39
18	136	Mike Connelly	0.292%	18	169	Jack Pardee	40.98	18	181	Dick Pesonen	39
19	193	Joe Krakoski	0.295%	19	59	Joe Schmidt	39.36	19	133	Tom Tracy	41
20	133	Tom Tracy	0.298%	20	135	Frank Clarke	37.60	20	139	Allen Green	50
21	169	Jack Pardee	0.298%	21	133	Tom Tracy	37.16	21	43	Bobby Walston	53
22	181	Dick Pesonen	0.304%	22	9	Max McGee	36.67	22	59	Joe Schmidt	53
23	176	Don Joyce	0.307%	23	163	Carroll Dale	34.30	23	103	Bob St. Clair	54
24	147	Ed Cook	0.314%	24	186	Frank Youso	34.22	24	41	Jess Richardson	57
25	36	Ted Dean	0.320%	25	153	Bill Koman	33.78	25	135	Frank Clarke	57
26	111	Mike Ditka	0.320%	26	34	Tom Brookshier	33.34	26	164	Art Hunter	61
27	41	Jess Richardson	0.323%	27	54	Darris McCord	32.79	27	48	Jim Gibbons	62
28	48	Jim Gibbons	0.323%	28	12	Bart Starr	31.97	28	82	Lenny Moore	66
29	67	Bob Mitchell	0.325%	29	90	John Unitas	31.54	29	24	Joe Morrison	67
30	73	Jim Ray Smith	0.325%	30	41	Jess Richardson	31.35	30	36	Ted Dean	69
31	82	Lenny Moore	0.325%	31	175	Rip Hawkins	27.93	31	62	Galen Fiss	69
32	92	John Brodie	0.325%	32	24	Joe Morrison	27.90	32	34	Tom Brookshier	70
33	188	Bill Anderson	0.331%	33	62	Galen Fiss	27.48	33	175	Rip Hawkins	70
34	59	Joe Schmidt	0.333%	34	48	Jim Gibbons	27.28	34	73	Jim Ray Smith	73
35	24	Joe Morrison	0.335%	35	82	Lenny Moore	26.10	35	188	Bill Anderson	73
36	62	Galen Fiss	0.336%	36	43	Bobby Walston	25.66	36	61	Jim Brown	74
37	135	Frank Clarke	0.336%	37	184	Fran Tarkenton	24.87	37	67	Bob Mitchell	76
38	171	Les Richter	0.336%	38	25	Dick Nolan	24.67	38	47	Gail Cogdill	80
39	175	Rip Hawkins	0.338%	39	13	Jim Taylor	24.47	39	55	Jim Martin	82
40	18	Bob Gaiters	0.342%	40	188	Bill Anderson	24.40	40	92	John Brodie	84
41	192	Jim Kerr	0.343%	41	15	Jesse Whittenton	23.22	41	147	Ed Cook	87
42	103	Bob St. Clair	0.347%	42	97	Jim Johnson	22.43	42	13	Jim Taylor	88
43	139	Allen Green	0.347%	43	73	Jim Ray Smith	21.65	43	186	Frank Youso	88
44	34	Tom Brookshier	0.348%	44	36	Ted Dean	21.39	44	18	Bob Gaiters	89
45	96	Matt Hazeltine	0.352%	45	8	Jerry Kramer	21.31	45	19	Roosevelt Grier	96
46	19	Roosevelt Grier	0.353%	46	158	Ralph Guglielmi	20.09	46	12	Bart Starr	97
47	51	Dick Lane	0.354%	47	67	Bob Mitchell	19.57	47	171	Les Richter	102
48	60	Harley Sewell	0.358%	48	78	Ordell Braase	18.51	48	97	Jim Johnson	105
49	13	Jim Taylor	0.365%	49	18	Bob Gaiters	18.23	49	154	Larry Wilson	109
50	107	Ed Brown	0.365%	50	19	Roosevelt Grier	18.15	50	189	Don Bosseler	109
51	87	Bill Pellington	0.374%	51	142	Don Meredith	18.15	51	190	Fred Hageman	111
52	154	Larry Wilson	0.375%	52	92	John Brodie	17.86	52	78	Ordell Braase	113
53	189	Don Bosseler	0.375%	53	190	Fred Hageman	17.68	53	75	Paul Wiggin	114
54	172	Frank Ryan	0.380%	54	164	Art Hunter	17.25	54	148	John David Crow	116
55	148	John David Crow	0.380%	55	75	Paul Wiggin	17.11	55	155	Dale Meinert	119
56	35	Jimmy Carr	0.387%	56	189	Don Bosseler	15.65	56	158	Ralph Guglielmi	119
57	63	Bob Gain	0.392%	57	154	Larry Wilson	15.44	57	51	Dick Lane	120
58	190	Fred Hageman	0.392%	58	155	Dale Meinert	15.40	58	192	Jim Kerr	121
59	75	Paul Wiggin	0.393%	59	140	Billy Howton	15.26	59	25	Dick Nolan	122
60	165	John LoVetere	0.397%	60	84	Steve Myhra	15.24	60	15	Jesse Whittenton	124
61	155	Dale Meinert	0.397%	61	148	John David Crow	14.61	61	200	Bob Toneff	130
62	200	Bob Toneff	0.397%	62	44	Chuck Weber	14.28	62	140	Billy Howton	133
63	97	Jim Johnson	0.403%	63	147	Ed Cook	14.23	63	68	John Morrow	136
64	186	Frank Youso	0.403%	64	171	Les Richter	14.15	64	182	Karl Rubke	137
65	78	Ordell Braase	0.407%	65	182	Karl Rubke	14.05	65	183	George Shaw	137
66	151	Prentice Gautt	0.407%	66	119	Bill Wade	14.00	66	141	Bob Lilly	140
67	2	Boyd Dowler	0.408%	67	55	Jim Martin	13.68	67	2	Boyd Dowler	141
68	183	George Shaw	0.413%	68	200	Bob Toneff	13.46	68	165	John LoVetere	141
69	12	Bart Starr	0.418%	69	183	George Shaw	12.94	69	172	Frank Ryan	141
70	123	Bobby Joe Green	0.419%	70	47	Gail Cogdill	12.94	70	119	Bill Wade	142
71	61	Jim Brown	0.419%	71	6	Paul Hornung	12.90	71	35	Jimmy Carr	145
72	182	Karl Rubke	0.419%	72	194	Fred Dugan	12.63	72	63	Bob Gain	145
73	158	Ralph Guglielmi	0.422%	73	51	Dick Lane	12.52	73	123	Bobby Joe Green	146
74	140	Billy Howton	0.422%	74	2	Boyd Dowler	12.41	74	44	Chuck Weber	147
75	104	Monty Stickles	0.422%	75	127	Gene Lipscomb	12.40	75	84	Steve Myhra	156
76	119	Bill Wade	0.422%	76	123	Bobby Joe Green	12.15	76	107	Ed Brown	156
77	23	Dick Lynch	0.424%	77	83	Jim Mutscheller	11.84	77	66	Gene Hickerson	166
78	79	Art Donovan	0.424%	78	66	Gene Hickerson	11.58	78	104	Monty Stickles	166
79	116	Johnny Morris	0.424%	79	11	Jim Ringo	11.13	79	129	John Nisby	167
80	42	Leo Sugar	0.424%	80	192	Jim Kerr	11.00	80	45	Ed Khayat	175
81	129	John Nisby	0.426%	81	165	John LoVetere	10.71	81	8	Jerry Kramer	178
82	157	Sonny Randle	0.431%	82	126	Bobby Layne	10.63	82	194	Fred Dugan	183
83	15	Jesse Whittenton	0.431%	83	134	Glynn Gregory	10.63	83	11	Jim Ringo	186
84	25	Dick Nolan	0.432%	84	45	Ed Khayat	10.58	84	79	Art Donovan	186
85	44	Chuck Weber	0.432%	85	33	Chuck Bednarik	10.50	85	121	Preston Carpenter	186
86	91	Bruce Bosley	0.436%	86	129	John Nisby	10.47	86	87	Bill Pellington	187
87	58	Nick Pietrosante	0.439%	87	172	Frank Ryan	10.45	87	151	Prentice Gautt	190
88	66	Gene Hickerson	0.439%	88	63	Bob Gain	10.37	88	198	Norman Snead	192
89	118	Richie Petitbon	0.441%	89	35	Jimmy Carr	9.99	89	60	Harley Sewell	193
90	102	J.D. Smith	0.441%	90	3	Bill Forester	9.79	90	118	Richie Petitbon	199
91	45	Ed Khayat	0.441%	91	104	Monty Stickles	9.66	91	127	Gene Lipscomb	199
92	22	Cliff Livingston	0.446%	92	198	Norman Snead	9.57	92	58	Nick Pietrosante	201
93	121	Preston Carpenter	0.448%	93	121	Preston Carpenter	9.56	93	90	John Unitas	207
94	161	Dick Bass	0.453%	94	81	Gino Marchetti	9.50	94	96	Matt Hazeltine	207
95	196	Vince Promuto	0.453%	95	65	Mike McCormack	9.49	95	177	Bill Lapham	207
96	84	Steve Myhra	0.455%	96	174	Grady Alderman	9.48	96	81	Gino Marchetti	211
97	80	Dee Mackey	0.457%	97	177	Bill Lapham	9.47	97	174	Grady Alderman	212
98	46	Howard Cassady	0.458%	98	5	Dave Hanner	9.21	98	65	Mike McCormack	218
99	94	Tommy Davis	0.468%	99	14	Fred Thurston	9.10	99	116	Johnny Morris	219
100	198	Norman Snead	0.480%	100	124	Mike Henry	9.02	100	122	Buddy Dial	221
101	130	John Reger	0.484%	101	115	Stan Jones	8.95	101	126	Bobby Layne	223
102	112	Joe Fortunato	0.491%	102	37	Sonny Jurgensen	8.88	102	23	Dick Lynch	225
103	38	Tommy McDonald	0.497%	103	114	Bill George	8.79	103	3	Bill Forester	226
104	173	Frank Varrichione	0.502%	104	76	Raymond Berry	8.75	104	180	Dave Middleton	227
105	56	Earl Morrall	0.506%	105	20	Sam Huff	8.70	105	83	Jim Mutscheller	232
106	180	Dave Middleton	0.506%	106	107	Ed Brown	8.69	106	168	Eddie Meador	233
107	11	Jim Ringo	0.507%	107	50	Alex Karras	8.65	107	134	Glynn Gregory	235
108	105	Abe Woodson	0.507%	108	79	Art Donovan	8.62	108	161	Dick Bass	236
109	159	Joe Childress	0.507%	109	122	Buddy Dial	8.60	109	184	Fran Tarkenton	236
110	177	Bill Lapham	0.507%	110	118	Richie Petitbon	8.55	110	86	Jim Parker	239
111	194	Fred Dugan	0.507%	111	7	Henry Jordan	8.54	111	112	Joe Fortunato	240
112	122	Buddy Dial	0.510%	112	86	Jim Parker	8.49	112	91	Bruce Bosley	242
113	146	J. W. Lockett	0.518%	113	162	Zeke Bratkowski	8.49	113	5	Dave Hanner	244
114	168	Eddie Meador	0.518%	114	58	Nick Pietrosante	8.44	114	22	Cliff Livingston	245
115	199	Andy Stynchula	0.518%	115	1	Dan Currie	8.36	115	179	Hugh McElhenny	246
116	174	Grady Alderman	0.519%	116	52	Yale Lary	8.35	116	114	Bill George	247
117	81	Gino Marchetti	0.523%	117	179	Hugh McElhenny	8.34	117	142	Don Meredith	247
118	40	Pete Retzlaff	0.523%	118	4	Forrest Gregg	8.29	118	94	Tommy Davis	248
119	49	Bill Glass	0.523%	119	168	Eddie Meador	8.15	119	162	Zeke Bratkowski	248
120	185	Mel Triplett	0.523%	120	68	John Morrow	8.12	120	125	John Henry Johnson	250
121	77	Bob Boyd	0.523%	121	180	Dave Middleton	8.09	121	199	Andy Stynchula	250
122	150	Frank Fuller	0.523%	122	125	John Henry Johnson	8.09	122	77	Bob Boyd	253
123	65	Mike McCormack	0.526%	123	143	Dick Moegle	8.04	123	157	Sonny Randle	253
124	127	Gene Lipscomb	0.530%	124	151	Prentice Gautt	7.95	124	20	Sam Huff	255
125	141	Bob Lilly	0.530%	125	131	Mike Sandusky	7.79	125	38	Tommy McDonald	255
126	100	Frank Morze	0.535%	126	32	Maxie Baughan	7.76	126	42	Leo Sugar	256
127	86	Jim Parker	0.536%	127	26	Andy Robustelli	7.59	127	100	Frank Morze	257
128	125	John Henry Johnson	0.536%	128	72	Dick Schafrath	7.55	128	72	Dick Schafrath	258
129	179	Hugh McElhenny	0.536%	129	187	Bill Bishop	7.48	129	130	John Reger	258
130	72	Dick Schafrath	0.540%	130	144	Don Perkins	7.45	130	159	Joe Childress	259
131	106	Doug Atkins	0.544%	131	100	Frank Morze	7.42	131	185	Mel Triplett	261
132	101	R.C. Owens	0.545%	132	77	Bob Boyd	7.33	132	146	J. W. Lockett	264
133	8	Jerry Kramer	0.545%	133	98	Billy Kilmer	7.25	133	56	Earl Morrall	266
134	99	Jerry Mertens	0.545%	134	166	Lamar Lundy	7.24	134	102	J.D. Smith	267
135	162	Zeke Bratkowski	0.545%	135	199	Andy Stynchula	7.22	135	32	Maxie Baughan	269
136	3	Bill Forester	0.546%	136	87	Bill Pellington	7.20	136	37	Sonny Jurgensen	270
137	109	Rick Casares	0.546%	137	137	L.G. Dupre	7.16	137	6	Paul Hornung	271
138	132	George Tarasovic	0.546%	138	112	Joe Fortunato	7.13	138	124	Mike Henry	271
139	85	Jimmy Orr	0.548%	139	27	Kyle Rote	7.03	139	40	Pete Retzlaff	272
140	89	Dick Szymanski	0.548%	140	116	Johnny Morris	7.02	140	46	Howard Cassady	272
141	126	Bobby Layne	0.548%	141	185	Mel Triplett	7.01	141	52	Yale Lary	272
142	21	Jim Katcavage	0.552%	142	161	Dick Bass	6.98	142	105	Abe Woodson	274
143	32	Maxie Baughan	0.552%	143	101	R.C. Owens	6.96	143	14	Fred Thurston	275
144	114	Bill George	0.552%	144	17	Roosevelt Brown	6.96	144	101	R.C. Owens	275
145	69	Bernie Parrish	0.559%	145	60	Harley Sewell	6.92	145	150	Frank Fuller	277
146	5	Dave Hanner	0.575%	146	109	Rick Casares	6.89	146	187	Bill Bishop	277
147	149	Sam Etcheverry	0.589%	147	64	Jim Houston	6.80	147	33	Chuck Bednarik	278
148	187	Bill Bishop	0.594%	148	23	Dick Lynch	6.72	148	115	Stan Jones	280
149	137	L.G. Dupre	0.595%	149	94	Tommy Davis	6.67	149	173	Frank Varrichione	282
150	20	Sam Huff	0.601%	150	159	Joe Childress	6.64	150	196	Vince Promuto	282
151	167	Ollie Matson	0.601%	151	146	J. W. Lockett	6.62	151	109	Rick Casares	283
152	134	Glynn Gregory	0.611%	152	38	Tommy McDonald	6.55	152	26	Andy Robustelli	286
153	170	Jim Phillips	0.611%	153	22	Cliff Livingston	6.54	153	137	L.G. Dupre	286
154	88	Alex Sandusky	0.624%	154	40	Pete Retzlaff	6.53	154	1	Dan Currie	287
155	83	Jim Mutscheller	0.624%	155	150	Frank Fuller	6.52	155	144	Don Perkins	287
156	52	Yale Lary	0.628%	156	91	Bruce Bosley	6.50	156	50	Alex Karras	289
157	144	Don Perkins	0.628%	157	130	John Reger	6.50	157	49	Bill Glass	291
158	191	Sam Horner	0.629%	158	21	Jim Katcavage	6.46	158	106	Doug Atkins	291
159	26	Andy Robustelli	0.629%	159	69	Bernie Parrish	6.40	159	7	Henry Jordan	294
160	27	Kyle Rote	0.629%	160	106	Doug Atkins	6.35	160	80	Dee Mackey	294
161	120	Maury Youmans	0.629%	161	56	Earl Morrall	6.32	161	76	Raymond Berry	296
162	138	Bob Fry	0.629%	162	96	Matt Hazeltine	6.25	162	98	Billy Kilmer	298
163	156	Ed Henke	0.645%	163	89	Dick Szymanski	6.23	163	131	Mike Sandusky	298
164	197	Joe Rutgens	0.649%	164	138	Bob Fry	6.20	164	27	Kyle Rote	299
165	98	Billy Kilmer	0.650%	165	120	Maury Youmans	6.20	165	21	Jim Katcavage	300
166	53	Dan Lewis	0.656%	166	105	Abe Woodson	6.14	166	89	Dick Szymanski	303
167	71	Ray Renfro	0.656%	167	149	Sam Etcheverry	6.06	167	69	Bernie Parrish	304
168	37	Sonny Jurgensen	0.671%	168	167	Ollie Matson	5.99	168	4	Forrest Gregg	305
169	16	Erich Barnes	0.689%	169	128	Lou Michaels	5.93	169	149	Sam Etcheverry	314
170	31	Billy Ray Barnes	0.699%	170	160	Jon Arnett	5.92	170	132	George Tarasovic	317
171	124	Mike Henry	0.709%	171	157	Sonny Randle	5.84	171	167	Ollie Matson	319
172	1	Dan Currie	0.711%	172	49	Bill Glass	5.84	172	143	Dick Moegle	320
173	131	Mike Sandusky	0.711%	173	70	Milt Plum	5.81	173	166	Lamar Lundy	320
174	57	Jim Ninowski	0.716%	174	46	Howard Cassady	5.76	174	64	Jim Houston	322
175	64	Jim Houston	0.717%	175	156	Ed Henke	5.72	175	120	Maury Youmans	326
176	14	Fred Thurston	0.721%	176	42	Leo Sugar	5.70	176	138	Bob Fry	326
177	108	J.C. Caroline	0.721%	177	102	J.D. Smith	5.68	177	17	Roosevelt Brown	328
178	90	John Unitas	0.732%	178	173	Frank Varrichione	5.60	178	85	Jimmy Orr	330
179	115	Stan Jones	0.737%	179	132	George Tarasovic	5.48	179	99	Jerry Mertens	333
180	195	John Paluck	0.748%	180	178	Tommy Mason	5.38	180	88	Alex Sandusky	335
181	39	Clarence Peaks	0.754%	181	88	Alex Sandusky	5.32	181	156	Ed Henke	338
182	50	Alex Karras	0.754%	182	57	Jim Ninowski	5.30	182	71	Ray Renfro	351
183	7	Henry Jordan	0.776%	183	152	Jimmy Hill	5.21	183	170	Jim Phillips	351
184	17	Roosevelt Brown	0.788%	184	71	Ray Renfro	5.15	184	191	Sam Horner	352
185	30	Alex Webster	0.797%	185	39	Clarence Peaks	5.12	185	31	Billy Ray Barnes	356
186	166	Lamar Lundy	0.797%	186	31	Billy Ray Barnes	5.10	186	57	Jim Ninowski	356
187	4	Forrest Gregg	0.804%	187	196	Vince Promuto	5.04	187	197	Joe Rutgens	356
188	95	Bob Harrison	0.804%	188	195	John Paluck	4.97	188	16	Erich Barnes	358
189	128	Lou Michaels	0.831%	189	16	Erich Barnes	4.95	189	128	Lou Michaels	358
190	70	Milt Plum	0.835%	190	30	Alex Webster	4.87	190	70	Milt Plum	363
191	178	Tommy Mason	0.836%	191	85	Jimmy Orr	4.78	191	160	Jon Arnett	365
192	76	Raymond Berry	0.838%	192	197	Joe Rutgens	4.64	192	39	Clarence Peaks	366
193	33	Chuck Bednarik	0.842%	193	95	Bob Harrison	4.60	193	53	Dan Lewis	366
194	113	Willie Galimore	0.842%	194	191	Sam Horner	4.51	194	195	John Paluck	368
195	160	Jon Arnett	0.852%	195	113	Willie Galimore	4.42	195	178	Tommy Mason	371
196	142	Don Meredith	0.865%	196	108	J.C. Caroline	4.42	196	108	J.C. Caroline	373
197	143	Dick Moegle	0.865%	197	80	Dee Mackey	4.35	197	30	Alex Webster	375
198	152	Jimmy Hill	0.924%	198	170	Jim Phillips	4.34	198	95	Bob Harrison	381
199	184	Fran Tarkenton	1.045%	199	99	Jerry Mertens	4.24	199	152	Jimmy Hill	381
200	6	Paul Hornung	1.209%	200	53	Dan Lewis	4.10	200	113	Willie Galimore	389